🎯 10 Best Newsletter Ads This Week (Apr 11–17)

👋 We’re back with our third round of newsletter ad breakdowns!

By now, you’ve probably noticed some patterns in what makes these ads work.

This week, we’ll look at 10 more fresh examples from Creator Spotlight, Sahil Bloom, Newseum, and more.

Let’s dive in and see what we can take away!

– Alex

📸 STATIC ADS

1. Creator Spotlight

Why this works:

To kick things off, we have Creator Spotlight’s brilliant ad. It taps into the growing frustration among content creators: Instagram growth is getting harder.

Using the notes app format instantly creates an authentic, peer-to-peer feel. They don’t dance around the problem – they name it directly: “reels views are down + hashtags don’t work.”

The ad immediately establishes credibility by mentioning their audience of 200,000+ creators. The social proof is especially powerful for creators who feel isolated in their growth struggles.

They promise practical insights from people who’ve already overcome the exact challenges their audience faces.

How to apply this concept:

• Lead with a specific pain point your target audience is experiencing right now, not a generic benefit.

• Use social proof as evidence your solution works (like “200,000+ creators read”).

• Choose an ad format that matches the expectations of your audience – the notes app feels authentic for creators.

2. Nomad for Less

Why this works:

Nomad for Less uses humor and contrast to highlight the absurdity of traditional work life. The “DON'T QUIT YOUR DAY JOB” headline grabs attention with its unexpected negativity.

Then, the checkmarks sarcastically list the “benefits” of staying put: working at the same desk for 40 years and retiring at 90.

The ad works because it creates an emotional reaction first – the feeling of being trapped – then offers an escape route. It doesn’t just promise new jobs; it promises a complete lifestyle change.

This speaks directly to people who feel stuck but aren’t sure how to take the first step toward location independence.

How to apply this concept:

• Use sarcasm or unexpected humor to highlight the pain of the status quo your newsletter helps solve.

• Create a clear contrast between the painful present and the desirable future your newsletter helps create.

• Focus on the emotional transformation your newsletter enables, not just its practical benefits.

3. The Open Letter

Why this works:

The Open Letter’s WhatsApp conversation format is genius for their target audience of South African professionals.

Rather than telling people why they should subscribe, they show a conversation where one person is amazed by the other’s insider knowledge. This peer recommendation feels more authentic than a marketing pitch.

The friend’s description of the newsletter as “like having a crystal ball” positions it as a competitive advantage in the professional world.

The closing line “Your future self will thank you” combines FOMO with a gentle nudge toward subscribing. 

How to apply this concept:

• Use conversational formats (text messages, chats) to simulate word-of-mouth recommendations.

• Position your newsletter as giving readers an edge/inside knowledge in their field.

• Create subtle FOMO by suggesting that not subscribing means missing out on valuable opportunities.

4. The Runway Ventures

Why this works:

Runway Ventures takes a bold approach here with its “exclusive content” pop-up style.

The ad doesn’t try to appeal to everyone. It deliberately filters out casual readers with the statement: “If you aren’t serious about becoming the top 1% founder, this isn’t for you.” This exclusivity is incredibly appealing to ambitious startup founders.

What makes this ad stand out, though, is its contrarian angle. Most startup content focuses on success stories, but Runway Ventures promises failed startup stories and lessons learned.

This different approach cuts through the noise in a very crowded space. It’s a practical structure founders can immediately apply.

How to apply this concept:

• Don’t be afraid to filter out non-ideal subscribers with bold statements about who should (and shouldn’t) subscribe.

• Look for untapped angles in your niche – what is everyone else NOT talking about?

• Create a consistent, numbered format that makes your content instantly useful and actionable.

5. Naples Brief

Why this works:

Naples Brief keeps it very simple. Against a beautiful backdrop of Naples’ scenery, they offer a clear value proposition. No complex pitches or gimmicks – just straightforward utility for people in Naples.

Specificity is king for local newsletters. By focusing exclusively on Naples, they create immediate relevance for residents and visitors. The beautiful background image works as a subtle emotional trigger.

And looking at the newsletter itself, it follows through on its promises with hyper-local content that delivers a ton of value.

How to apply this concept:

• For location-specific newsletters, use imagery that evokes the beauty or unique character of your area.

• Keep your value proposition extremely simple – people subscribe to local newsletters for clear, practical benefits.

• Emphasize “FREE” to remove any barrier to subscription, especially for local content.

6. Cyber Corsairs

Why this works:

We featured Cyber Corsairs in our first issue, and they’re back with another winning ad that uses their proven cheat sheet format.

Just like before, they’re giving away genuinely useful content. But this time, they’ve organized ChatGPT prompt frameworks alongside practical tips.

And the intentional typo (“guid” instead of “guide”) is actually a clever marketing trick. It adds authenticity and can boost engagement as people feel compelled to point it out.

Additionally, the original $100 price (now crossed out) creates the perception of getting premium content for free. 

How to apply this concept:

• Give away genuinely useful content in your ad – make the ad itself valuable even if people don’t subscribe.

• Use structured formats like cheat sheets or quick-reference guides to showcase the practical nature of your newsletter.

• Consider intentional “imperfections” that make your ad feel more authentic and less corporate.

🎬 VIDEO ADS

7. Sahil Bloom

Why this works:

Sahil Bloom’s video ad delivers a powerful motivational message first, then introduces the newsletter as the solution.

“Your entire life can change in one year” creates an emotional response of hope, determination, and possibility.

But, it’s important to note that this is before asking for any action. The order matters: emotion first, call-to-action second.

Videos, compared to text alone, usually allow creators to connect more personally with their audience.

His direct challenge – “what’s stopping you from starting today?” – creates tension that the newsletter subscription fixes. The promise is comprehensive but simple: “healthier, wealthier, and happier.” 

How to apply this concept:

• Lead with an emotionally resonant message before introducing your newsletter.

• Use videos to create a more personal connection with potential subscribers.

• Frame your newsletter as the bridge between where subscribers are now and where they want to be.

8. DTC Newsletter

Why this works:

DTC Newsletter’s TikTok-style ad perfectly channels the insecurity many marketers have about staying relevant.

The humor is unboastful but relatable: “When you’re supposed to be an expert marketer, but you steal all of your ideas from a free marketing newsletter.” This speaks directly to the imposter syndrome many professionals experience.

The ad works because it positions the newsletter as the secret weapon behind successful marketers. Rather than promising to make you a marketing expert, it suggests that current marketing experts are already using it.

The TikTok format with lip-syncing also matches where their target audience already spends time.

How to apply this concept:

• Use humor that taps into common insecurities your newsletter helps solve.

• Position your newsletter as an “insider secret” that successful people already use.

• Match your ad format to the platforms where your target audience naturally spends their time.

9. Newseum

Why this works:

Newseum’s ad tackles a universal challenge: burnout. And it addresses it with a powerful counterclaim: “burnout doesn’t have to be your normal.”

It also has background footage of Elon Musk (a figure known for extreme work ethic). All of this immediately grabs attention from tired professionals.

What makes this ad particularly effective is its promise of a better way. It doesn’t just acknowledge burnout; it offers “proven strategies from top CEOs” to stay productive “without working harder.”

The simple call-to-action – “subscribe to Newseum” – provides an easy first step toward solving this painful problem.

How to apply this concept:

• Address a widespread pain point that your target audience may have normalized.

• Challenge conventional wisdom about what’s necessary in your field.

• Position your newsletter as providing insider strategies that aren’t widely known.

10. The Points Guy

Why this works:

Wrapping up our analysis this week is The Points Guy’s video ad. It opens with a powerful hook: “This is the number one mistake people make with their credit card points.”

This immediately indicates valuable insider knowledge that could save viewers from a common error.

The ad then creates a contrast between what most people do (waste points on gift cards or groceries) and what savvy travelers do (transfer to premium partners). 

The promise is specific and aspirational: “double or even triple the value of your points” to get “amazing first class flights, VIP lounge visits, and dream vacations.”

The changing backgrounds and visuals make these benefits feel tangible. Social proof – “over a million savvy travelers trust our insider tips” – like always, reduces skepticism. 

How to apply this concept:

• Start with a specific mistake your audience is making that your newsletter helps solve.

• Create a clear contrast between common practice and the better approach your newsletter teaches.

• Use visuals that help subscribers imagine enjoying the benefits your newsletter enables.

Hope you enjoyed this Thursday’s breakdown! Catch you in a week with more ad insights! You can view our past issues on our website.

P.S. Got a question with your newsletter? Whether it's:

• 📈 Growing your newsletter with paid ads

• 🐝 Beehiiv tips, customization, or feature guidance (If you're thinking about switching to beehiiv, use this link to get your first month FREE + 20% off the next 3 months.)

• 💰 Monetization strategies like sponsorships, paid subscriptions, Sparkloop integrations, etc.

Just hit reply and let me know what's on your mind – I'll do my best to help.